11/18/2026

Ethos supports the proposed amendments to the Banking Act, the final part of the ‘too big to fail’ reform, but calls for them to be strengthened in three areas: capping variable remuneration for senior executives, ensuring their individual accountability, and incorporating climate and environmental risks.

Ethos has been committed to promoting best practices in corporate governance among companies listed in Switzerland for nearly 30 years. This also applies to large listed banks, which pose a systemic risk to both the country’s economy and their shareholders. Whether through its shareholder engagement activities or its voting recommendations at general meetings, Ethos’s objective remains to foster the sustainable success of companies, in the interests of their shareholders and all their stakeholders.

Banking regulation, and more specifically the reform of the ‘too big to fail’ framework initiated following the collapse of Credit Suisse, represents an opportunity to strengthen the stability of the banking system, while also addressing the incentives and accountability of senior executives. Excessive risk-taking by bank executives has been at the root of numerous scandals in recent years, including those that precipitated the bank’s collapse. Following the takeover of Credit Suisse, the systemic risk posed by UBS cannot be ignored, with a balance sheet total equivalent to 1.7 times Switzerland’s gross domestic product at the end of 2025.

Having already participated in the first two consultation rounds on this matter – concerning capital adequacy requirements (the Capital Adequacy Ordinance and the deduction of foreign shareholdings) – and having supported the Federal Council’s proposals, Ethos is setting out its position on the third and final phase of the reform: the amendment to the Banking Act. This was open for consultation until 19 November 2026.

Ethos welcomes the legal enshrinement of governance requirements, the introduction of a liability regime, the first statutory rules on remuneration systems and the strengthening of FINMA’s instruments. However, Ethos believes that the draft amendment presented by the Federal Council needs to be strengthened in three key areas.

Limiting variable remuneration to reduce risks

Firstly, Ethos advocates introducing a statutory cap on variable remuneration for members of executive management and other “key risk-takers” at all banks listed in Switzerland, not just UBS. Based on the practice in the European Union since 2014, Ethos thus considers that total variable remuneration, including annual bonuses and long-term variable remuneration schemes, should not exceed 100 % of fixed remuneration, or 200 % with the approval of the general meeting.

Ethos believes that such a requirement is justified for listed banks, particularly those whose failure could threaten financial stability and necessitate state intervention, as occurred in 2008 and 2023. “A shareholder vote is necessary, but unfortunately it is not enough to limit the incentives for excessive risk-taking by the executives of listed banks. For these institutions, limiting such incentives is in the public interest and cannot be left solely to the discretion of shareholders,” emphasises Vincent Kaufmann, CEO of the Ethos Foundation.

Ethos also proposes that deferred variable remuneration be held in a special-purpose vehicle (SPV) for the entire deferral period – at least five years – in order to absorb any subsequent losses. This would prevent profits from being privatised while losses are socialised. It would also facilitate, from a technical standpoint, the clawback of bonuses. Finally, it would constitute a loss-absorption mechanism that could be drawn upon as a priority, before Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital.

Secondly, Ethos calls for individual accountability to be effectively established and made transparent, with sanctions for non-compliance, including in the event of resolution. In practical terms, listed banks should inform the general meeting of the findings of internal investigations following losses or serious breaches The resolution procedure should also not permit the exclusion of liability claims against governing bodies, nor the payment of variable remuneration or severance pay to outgoing executives.

Finally, Ethos calls for climate- and nature-related financial risks to be explicitly incorporated into risk management requirements, as is already the case under the Basel Committee regulations. This provision would provide an explicit legal basis for the FINMA circular on nature-related financial risks, which has been in force since 1 January 2026. Ethos also calls for crisis scenarios and stabilisation plans for systemically important banks to incorporate climate risks, and for the ESG criteria for variable remuneration to be based on measurable and disclosed targets.

Ethos position statement (in French)

News
Corporate Governance
Remuneration